Biopics have become a cultural mainstay in modern entertainment, offering a dramatic lens into the lives of icons, from political leaders to musical legends. Films like Bohemian Rhapsody, Elvis, and Rocketman not only bring past generations to life but also offer deep dives into the behind-the-scenes triumphs and tribulations of famous figures. However, these cinematic portrayals often stir up controversy, especially among those who lived the story firsthand.
One such person is actress and television personality Valerie Bertinelli, who recently made headlines with her candid take on the idea of a Van Halen biopic. During a moment of raw honesty, Bertinelli made it abundantly clear that she is not on board with the idea—at least not while she’s still alive. Her exact words? “Make sure I’m dead.”
The 64-year-old One Day at a Time star was married to legendary guitarist Eddie Van Halen for over two decades, and though they divorced in 2007, their relationship—and Eddie’s legacy—remains deeply intertwined with her public identity.
Let’s unpack the layers of Bertinelli’s powerful statement, explore the cultural context of biopics, and ask the bigger question: who gets to control a legacy once it’s in the public eye?
Valerie Bertinelli and Eddie Van Halen: A Legacy of Love, Pain, and Loyalty
Valerie Bertinelli and Eddie Van Halen’s marriage was far from picture-perfect, but it was rooted in a bond that transcended the ordinary. The couple wed in 1981 at the height of Van Halen’s fame and had a son, Wolfgang Van Halen, who would later join the band as bassist. Throughout their marriage—and even after their split—the two remained close, especially during Eddie’s long battle with cancer.
When Eddie passed away in 2020, Valerie shared a heartbreaking tribute, detailing the profound love they shared despite the eventual end of their marriage. In her memoir Enough Already: Learning to Love the Way I Am Today, she wrote extensively about their relationship, peeling back the curtain on both their affection and their struggles.
Given this intimate connection, Bertinelli’s reaction to the possibility of a biopic isn’t just a soundbite—it’s a protective declaration. One rooted in lived experience, personal trauma, and fierce loyalty to the man behind the legend.
Why Biopics Strike a Nerve: Authenticity vs. Exploitation
Bertinelli’s blunt reaction speaks to a broader cultural tension around biopics. While these films are marketed as “tributes” to greatness, they often raise uncomfortable questions:
- Who gets to tell the story?
- What parts are dramatized, and what is left out?
- And most importantly, who benefits from the telling?
In Bertinelli’s case, her comment likely stems from concern over being misrepresented—or worse, used as narrative fodder. As someone who has been portrayed in media for over four decades, she’s well aware of how Hollywood can distort the truth for the sake of entertainment.
The success of recent biopics like Bohemian Rhapsody (Freddie Mercury), Elvis, and Blonde (Marilyn Monroe) has shown that even critically acclaimed films can face backlash. Whether it’s family members objecting to the portrayal, or historians critiquing factual inaccuracies, there’s always a tightrope to walk between creative license and respectful representation.
Bertinelli isn’t just rejecting the idea of a Van Halen biopic for the sake of it. Her resistance likely stems from a desire to preserve the sanctity of a very real, very personal part of her life—a chapter that she may not want adapted into a screenplay by people who weren’t there.
Wolfgang Van Halen’s Voice Matters—But So Does Valerie’s
An interesting wrinkle in this discussion is the involvement—or potential involvement—of Wolfgang Van Halen, Eddie and Valerie’s son. Wolfgang has been a vocal advocate for preserving his father’s legacy on his own terms. With his solo project Mammoth WVH, he’s walked a fine line between honoring his roots and establishing his own identity.
Should a Van Halen biopic ever be greenlit, Wolfgang’s approval (or lack thereof) would likely carry significant weight. However, Valerie’s perspective is just as vital. After all, she was there for the rise, the fall, the heartbreaks, and the late-night jam sessions that never made the headlines.
Her lived experience isn’t just supplementary—it’s central. And her request to “make sure I’m dead” before dramatizing it all? That’s a plea for dignity. A reminder that for every legend, there’s a life, often messy, painful, and intensely human.
Hollywood’s Love Affair with Rock Star Dramas
There’s no denying that biopics about musicians have a certain cinematic appeal. They’re filled with drama, passion, and often tragedy—an irresistible cocktail for screenwriters and studios alike. Van Halen, with its rags-to-riches story, internal band conflict, and larger-than-life frontmen, is prime biopic material.
But that same dramatic potential is what makes Valerie Bertinelli’s stance all the more compelling. In a world eager to mine nostalgia for profit, her resistance serves as a gut check.
It raises the ethical question: should a story as personal and intricate as Eddie Van Halen’s be fictionalized for mass consumption, especially if the people closest to him haven’t given their blessing?
The Cultural Shift: Consent and the Right to Legacy
We are witnessing a cultural shift in how public figures—and their families—engage with legacy. From unauthorized documentaries to posthumous albums, the line between tribute and exploitation is blurrier than ever.
Bertinelli’s no-nonsense take reflects a growing sentiment: consent matters, even after death. While some artists might welcome a biopic as a form of legacy-building, others see it as a potential misstep, especially when crafted by people who didn’t share the journey.
Valerie’s statement also challenges the industry to do better—to approach such stories with integrity, transparency, and compassion. Because when it comes to real lives, real families, and real love stories, the stakes are simply too high for sensationalism.
A Biopic Isn’t Always a Tribute—Sometimes, It’s a Breach
Valerie Bertinelli’s viral remark—“Make sure I’m dead”—isn’t just a punchline for entertainment headlines. It’s a profound statement about ownership, grief, and the delicate balance between public interest and private reality.
As fans, we often want to know more, see more, feel more of the stories behind the music that shaped us. But those stories are often more than entertainment—they’re someone’s life.
Whether or not a Van Halen biopic ever comes to fruition, Bertinelli’s boundary-setting moment reminds us of something essential: just because a story is compelling doesn’t mean it’s ours to tell.
Until that time—if it ever comes—it’s probably best to let sleeping guitars lie. Or, at the very least, wait until those who lived the chords and chaos have had the final word.
Leave a Reply